If your trail runs regularly include rocky climbs, muddy descents, and debris-covered paths, the Merrell Agility Peak 5 feels purpose-built for that kind of terrain. I’ve tested it on mixed, unpredictable trails, and for a well-cushioned shoe, it comes across as surprisingly agile. The level of protection is high, but it never feels cumbersome. Right out of the box, the midsole delivers a smooth, responsive ride with enough energy return to handle surges in pace or quick changes in direction.
Underfoot confidence is where the shoe really stands out. The chevron-shaped Vibram lugs bite reliably into loose dirt, wet grass, and slick rock, making traction feel consistent rather than situational. The ride stays stable across technical sections, with a secure, locked-in feel that encourages you to trust your footing when the trail gets rough. It’s a versatile trail workhorse—comfortable and protective for ultra-distance efforts, yet responsive enough for faster runs on rugged terrain.
Table of Contents
- Key Specs at a Glance
- Design & Build Overview
- Fit, Upper & Comfort
- Cushioning & Ride Feel
- Traction & Stability
- Durability & Value
- Pros & Cons
- Who Should Buy the Merrell Agility Peak 5
- Final Verdict
- Merrell Agility Peak 5 FAQs
Merrell Agility Peak 5 Infographic
Key Specs at a Glance
- Heel-to-toe drop: 6 mm
- Weight: 8.29 oz (women), 10.58 oz (men)
- Stack height: 31/25 mm
- Midsole foam: FloatPro
- Outsole: Vibram MegaGrip
- Lug: 5 mm
- Intended use: Rugged and technical trail
Design & Build Overview
At first glance, the Merrell Agility Peak 5 looks every bit like a serious trail shoe—rugged, purposeful, and clearly built for off-road work. It feels similar to my Hoka Speedgoat 6, and visually, the comparison makes sense. On the run, though, it quickly separates itself. Despite weighing 8.29 oz for women and 10.58 oz for men, it never feels heavy on foot. I’ve taken it through road connectors and straight into technical trails, and the transition always feels smooth. The 31 mm heel / 25 mm forefoot stack hits a balanced zone: cushioned enough for long miles, but still low and stable enough to stay connected to uneven ground.
The 6 mm drop also feels like a smart, trail-friendly choice. It takes some strain off the Achilles and calves without forcing an unnatural stride, which I appreciated on longer outings when fatigue starts to creep in. Underfoot, the Agility Peak 5 runs firmer than the Speedgoat 6, and that’s a good thing if you value control. That slightly stiffer platform delivers a more planted, confidence-inspiring ride, especially on rocky or unpredictable terrain. It’s not about plush softness here; it’s about stability, trust, and consistency when the trail gets demanding.
Fit, Upper & Comfort of the Merrell Agility Peak 5
The Merrell Agility Peak 5 fits true to size, though the toe box does lean slightly narrow. If you like a lot of forefoot space, that’s worth keeping in mind. For my foot, the fit feels secure, and the overall lockdown is excellent. The shoe wraps the foot in a way that feels ready to go from the first stride, with no break-in needed.
The gusseted tongue adds to that secure feel by keeping dust, small rocks, and trail debris out while providing light midfoot compression. The tongue does run a bit short, which makes fine adjustments slightly less convenient, but once dialed in, it stays put. The engineered mesh and TPU upper strike a good balance between protection and breathability. Even on warmer runs, ventilation is solid, and the upper conforms naturally around the heel and midfoot without creating pressure points or hot spots.
Underfoot, the FloatPro Foam midsole is where the Agility Peak 5 really delivers. The cushioning feels soft yet controlled, especially under the heel where the absence of a rock plate allows for smoother landings. On uneven terrain, the foam remains responsive and stable, helping the shoe feel nimble rather than cumbersome. Over longer, technical runs, comfort holds up well, making it easy to stay focused on the trail instead of what’s happening underfoot.
Cushioning & Ride Feel of the Merrell Agility Peak 5
The FloatPro midsole is where the Merrell Agility Peak 5 really earns its keep. From my first run, it stood out for how well it balances stability and cushioning. There’s enough firmness to keep the platform composed on uneven terrain, but it never crosses into feeling harsh or unforgiving. On steep climbs, fast descents, and constant direction changes, the midsole stays predictable and controlled, which makes a big difference when the trail gets technical.
On the move, the ride feels responsive and surprisingly nimble for a shoe built this tough. Underfoot, it feels lighter than expected, and that helps maintain a smooth, efficient stride across mixed terrain. I also appreciated how well it handled short pavement sections—no awkward stiffness or clunky transitions, just a balanced feel that doesn’t punish you when the trail briefly disappears.
When it’s time to push the pace, the Agility Peak 5 responds without hesitation. The midsole provides a subtle rebound that keeps you moving forward and helps limit fatigue as the miles add up. Whether I’m settling into a steady rhythm on technical trails or easing into a recovery effort, the ride stays consistent, comfortable, and confidence-inspiring from start to finish.
Traction & Stability of the Merrell Agility Peak 5
Merrell got the outsole right on the Agility Peak 5. In my runs, the Vibram MegaGrip rubber delivered consistent, trustworthy traction across a wide range of surfaces. Pavement sections, loose dirt, slick grass, and wet rock all felt manageable, with grip that stayed predictable rather than sketchy. The outsole doesn’t just feel sticky; it feels controlled, which is exactly what you want when footing starts to matter.
The chevron-shaped lugs play a big role in that confidence. They’re aggressive enough to bite into soft ground and loose terrain, but not so rigid that they slow you down. I was able to change direction quickly and pick up the pace without feeling like the shoe was fighting me. Mud shedding is also excellent; even in sloppy conditions, the outsole resists clogging, helping the shoe stay light and responsive as the trail deteriorates.
Stability underfoot is another strong point. On technical sections, the Agility Peak 5 feels planted and composed, reducing that uneasy side-to-side movement that can creep in on uneven ground. Through deep mud or slick grass, it holds its line and maintains balance, reinforcing that this is a shoe built for runners who want confidence when the trail turns demanding.
Durability & Value of the Merrell Agility Peak 5
The Merrell Agility Peak 5 is clearly built for long-term use. Based on my experience, it’s reasonable to expect around 300 to 500 miles from this shoe, even with regular exposure to rough, demanding trails. The Vibram MegaGrip outsole holds up especially well on rocky and abrasive surfaces, with the lugs maintaining their shape and traction rather than rounding off early. The upper also feels well reinforced, handling roots, mud, and trail debris without signs of premature wear.
Durability extends beyond just the outsole. The upper materials feel tough without being overly stiff, and after repeated runs, there’s no fraying or weak spots showing up. It’s the kind of shoe you can put through consistent training cycles and still trust for long runs later in the season. Everything about the build suggests it was designed to handle abuse, not just look the part.
At $150 retail, the Agility Peak 5 already offers strong value given its grip, cushioning, and durability. I was pleasantly surprised to find a pair locally for $120 at regular shelf price, which made it an even easier buy. For runners who need a dependable, long-lasting trail shoe that can handle real mileage and varied terrain, the Agility Peak 5 stands out as one of Merrell’s most practical and reliable options.
Pros & Cons
Here’s a quick, pros & cons summary for the Merrell Agility Peak 5, based on how it performs in real trail conditions.
Pros
- Excellent traction: The Vibram MegaGrip outsole with chevron-shaped lugs bites aggressively into any terrain—mud, wet grass, loose dirt, or rock—while shedding debris efficiently.
- Stable ride: The FloatPro midsole provides just the right stiffness for a controlled, balanced feel on uneven trails, keeping you steady even with quick pace and direction changes.
- Comfortable cushioning: The FloatPro foam feels light, responsive, and protective underfoot, especially over long distances or rugged terrain.
- Secure lockdown: The gusseted tongue and snug upper hold the foot well, preventing slipping or debris entry without causing pressure points.
- Breathable upper: The engineered mesh and TPU design keep your feet cool and ventilated, even on hot days.
- Durable build: Expect 300–500 miles of solid performance; both outsole and upper materials show excellent wear resistance.
- Good value for money: At $150 retail, or even better if you find it closer to $120, it delivers top-tier traction, stability, and comfort for the price.
Cons
- Narrow toe box: Fit runs slightly narrow up front, which may feel snug for wide-footed runners.
- Firm midsole feel: The FloatPro foam prioritizes stability over plushness, so those wanting a softer, “max-cushion” sensation may find it too firm.
- Short tongue design: The tongue lacks pull leverage, making adjustments slightly tricky during fit tweaks.
- Not ideal for sockless running: Rubbing under the tongue can occur if worn without socks.
- Slightly heavy on paper: At 10.58 oz, it’s not the lightest trail shoe, but it feels lighter than the numbers suggest once you’re moving.
Who Should Buy the Merrell Agility Peak 5
Here’s a clear snapshot of who should (and shouldn’t) consider the Merrell Agility Peak 5, based on how it performs across trail conditions and running styles.
Who Should Buy It
- Trail runners who crave traction and stability. If you often deal with rocky paths, deep mud, or slippery grass, the Vibram MegaGrip outsole gives you confidence with every step.
- Runners looking for a versatile, all-terrain workhorse. The Agility Peak 5 handles everything from technical singletracks to light pavement without feeling awkward or unstable.
- Those who value long-distance comfort and protection. The FloatPro midsole keeps your legs fresher over long runs by reducing fatigue and absorbing shock efficiently.
- Runners with neutral to slightly unstable strides. The firm, balanced midsole offers great support without feeling like a motion-control shoe.
- Trail athletes training or racing in mixed conditions. Whether it’s wet, dry, or unpredictable, this shoe grips and performs consistently.
Who Shouldn’t Buy It
- Runners with wide feet. The toe box runs narrow and may feel cramped during long runs or hot conditions.
- Those who prefer a plush, soft ride. The midsole leans firm and stable rather than pillowy, so maximalists may find it less cushioned.
- Minimalist runners. If you enjoy ground feel and flexibility, the Agility Peak 5’s protective build will feel too stiff.
- Runners who frequently go sockless. The inner tongue can cause friction without socks, especially on hot days.
Final Verdict
The Merrell Agility Peak 5 stands out as a dependable, confidence-inspiring trail shoe that performs consistently across demanding terrain. In my runs, it strikes a rare balance between grip, comfort, and stability, feeling equally capable on rocky climbs, muddy sections, and uneven ground.
The FloatPro midsole sits in a well-judged zone—firm enough to stay composed on technical trails yet cushioned enough to remain comfortable as the miles add up. Paired with the Vibram MegaGrip outsole and its aggressive chevron lugs, traction feels reliable and predictable, even on wet rock and loose surfaces.
It’s not without compromises. The toe box runs a bit narrow, and the ride leans firmer rather than plush. That said, those trade-offs translate into better control, stability, and durability where it matters most. At its $150 retail price, the Merrell Agility Peak 5 offers strong value for trail runners who prioritize surefooted performance and long-term reliability over soft, cushy feel.
Merrell Agility Peak 5 FAQs
Before you hit the trails, here are some common questions runners ask about the Merrell Agility Peak 5, and what you should know before buying:
Is the Merrell Agility Peak 5 true to size?
Yes, it fits true to size for most runners. However, the toe box runs slightly narrow, so if you have wide feet, you may want to try a half-size up or wear thinner socks.
How does it perform on wet or muddy terrain?
Exceptionally well. The Vibram MegaGrip outsole with chevron-shaped lugs provides excellent traction on wet rock, deep mud, and slippery grass. It also sheds debris and mud efficiently to keep your stride smooth.
Can I use the Agility Peak 5 for hiking?
Absolutely. Its stable ride, protective cushioning, and durable outsole make it a great hybrid for trail running and light hiking. Many users even prefer it for long hikes due to its balance of comfort and grip.
Is the shoe comfortable for long-distance trail runs?
Yes. The FloatPro midsole offers reliable comfort and responsiveness that hold up over long distances. It’s firm enough to stay stable yet soft enough to keep your legs fresh after hours on the trail.
How durable is the outsole and upper?
You can expect around 300–500 miles before significant wear shows. The Vibram outsole is extremely durable, and the TPU-reinforced mesh upper holds up well against rocks, roots, and debris.
Is the Merrell Agility Peak 5 good for road running?
It can handle short pavement stretches comfortably, but it’s primarily designed for trails. The firm midsole and aggressive lugs make it less efficient on pure road runs, though it transitions smoothly when terrain changes.
Is it worth the price?
Definitely. For around $150 (or $120 if you find a deal), you’re getting a shoe that delivers premium traction, protection, and durability, making it one of the best-value trail runners in its class.
You may also like:
